I’m not sure where I stand on this issue, really. I’ve been reading a lot about it from a couple of authors, George R. R. Martin on his Not A Blog, and also Diana Gabaldon on her blog: Voyages of Artemis about their dislike of people using their works for fanfiction and their dislike of fanfiction in general.
I remember when I realized I’d actually been writing fanfiction. When I first started writing I flipped between writing about two sisters who had found an otter, this was after I first saw “Ring of Bright Water” and about the Tracy boys from “Thunderbirds” discovering they had a sister called Cassiopeia. I would write this dross in notebooks between classes. It entertained me greatly for a little while. I even branched out trying to speculate on the origin story of Superman and Supergirl. I named them Lyte and Darke–so creative and tried to understand where they came from. Then I actually saw the original Superman movie and the Supergirl movie and well, I was extremely disappointed in the latter, but enthralled by the former.
Then I began finding inspiration for my own stories based on the plot holes of others. There were a great many nitpicks I had with some television shows and stories that I was seeing and I started to write my own stories that were similar. I worked out planets and races and started on time lines. Originally I was writing out plot lines in the fashion of episodes, but then I was twelve. I had a lot to learn about writing. I continued off and on with my own work in between school and things like that. When I got to college I met several people who wrote fanfiction avidly. We would speculate about things that characters would do in certain situations and would write. I do get a charge when someone tells me, “OMG it’s like you envisioned X perfectly,” or something of that nature, but as I’ve gotten older I feel a bit more guilty about the idea of writing in someone else’s universe. I know that I would not be seeking money from it, but I suppose it’s the differing perspective that comes with age, and the fact that I’m much more focused on my own goals of one day getting published and have a better ability to see things in someone else’s shoes. I wonder, how would I feel if someone ‘toyed’ with my characters? Would I be happy? flattered? disgusted?
I admit there are several times I’ve seen descriptions of fanfiction and I’m going “by the Gods that’s vile.” a lot of it is drivel, much as my early ten year old work, whether fanfiction or not was utter drivel. As you get older your skills at many things improve. When I was ten I could barely scramble eggs and now I can prepare a four course meal, provided I have the spoons.
There’ve been times when I have still dabbled in fanfiction as a way to detox and do things mindlessly and I…I just don’t know any more. I recently changed the intro to my fanfiction.net account saying that I felt that I could no longer in good conscience write fanfiction because I feel so guilty.
My commentary sparked an interesting debate within our house because the idea was postulated that once you publish a book it becomes “public domain” and the whole “this is why there are disclaimers on fanfiction” and I’m thinking well that’s true but for the thousand honest fans who just want to express their love by writing about your characters, it just takes one douchebag to in that sense “ruin it” for everyone else; to take what you’ve written and rip it off. While from some of the less flame-tastic comments I’ve been reading on various blog articles speak of the fact that most communities have strict rules about who they can and cannot take fanfiction works about and how many communities will troll, roast and oust those who “break the rules” and demand payment for fanfiction or try to take credit for things they cannot.
I suppose it is personal taste. There’s so much of me in characters I write in a variety of ways that I feel that I would take great exception to finding my characters in the compromising and heinous situations that I’ve seen many characters put in and through. However at the same time it’s finding the healthy balance between being an evil ogre and being a poor sap. I’ve been run over so many times in my life, that I wouldn’t want to shoot myself in the foot in either score.
Still, most of this is purely speculative in the sense that I’m taking liberties even assuming I might ever get published. I may be getting better with writing but I still have a ways to go before any of the nuggets going through my brain become anything resembling publishable; but I don’t want it to be something I think about too little or remember too late. From what I’m reading there are many authors out there who aren’t even aware that there is fan fiction and yet there are others who know of it and condone and encourage it: Joss Whedon and J.K. Rowling are two of those from what I understand. I have to wonder how they make it work.